Question on "Public Service"

User offline. Last seen 12 years 32 weeks ago.
Nich
Number 632
Conspirator for: 15 years 5 weeks
Posted on: October 21, 2009 - 5:38pm

I've been studying the ideas of libertarianism and objectivism and I'm having an issue with this.

My university has several programs that offers some sort of community serivce either locally or internationally.  I do like helping people, but I seem to face a moral dilemma whenever I think about actually volunteering.

The first thing that comes to my mind is out of Ayn Rand's "We the Living".  I can't help but think of how they were forced into some sort of club or group for the public good and that they could lose their jobs if they didn't do enough for society.  The second issue I'm dealing with is the people themselves in such groups, the ones who think it's their civic duty to help others.  It bothers the hell out of me; performing a task where you are not the benefituary is not rational, and helping with this mindset is just that: irrational.

Sure, I'd like to help some underprivilaged youth who have no mentors, but this term public service just drives me away.


User offline. Last seen 9 years 51 weeks ago.
FUR3jr
Number 468
FUR3jr's picture
Conspirator for: 16 years 6 weeks
Posted on: October 21, 2009 - 8:57pm #1

I somewhat regularly perform benevolent acts.  I never perform acts of "community service."  I hate the term "community" because, by definition, those people that form the "community" live under the thumb of the government.  People are sentenced to community service for stepping out of line with the local oligarchs.

I think that you should engage in benevolent acts, and not community service.  Maybe there is a benevolent society which helps some needy group of people in your area.


User offline. Last seen 12 years 32 weeks ago.
Nich
Number 632
Conspirator for: 15 years 5 weeks
Posted on: October 22, 2009 - 12:30am #2

Yeah, shying as much away from collectivist terms as possible.  Benevolent acts is a much better term because it can never imply duty.


User offline. Last seen 15 years 5 weeks ago.
Brewhore
Number 633
Conspirator for: 15 years 5 weeks
Posted on: October 23, 2009 - 9:43am #3

If you consider yourself an objectivist, and wish to follow Ayn Rand's philosophies, first keep in mind that We the Living was a first attempt at her philosophy and in her later years she did not like We the Living, because it did not portray her philosophy properly.  So, if you're concerned with what Ayn Rand would think on the subject look at Atlas Shrugged.  And in her ideal society set in the mountains where the elders would take on apprentices and teach them despite the fact that it was not monetarily prudent to do so.  The payoff in helping other humans is paid in mental well-being.  If you keep in mind that it makes YOU feel good to help others, then there is no conflict of ideals here.  You are volunteering your time because you feel you are a benefit to someone else, and you get satisfaction from that.  That is a quite Libertarian and Objectivist philosophy.

Also, while I understand the annoyance of the self-righteous people you find in volunteer groups. Have patience with them.  Keep in mind that their hearts are in the right place.  This is an opportunity to educate.  My suggestion is to go and give of yourself first, and keep your mouth shut about your ideals.  Let them decide they like you, and accept you as one of them, and then you may start explaining to them the fallacies in their logic. 

If you're inclined to do volunteer work, do it.  Don't let the reasons you posted above stop you.  Also, make sure you find something you love doing. If you volunteer on your own terms, and don't ever feel as if you have to, you will always enjoy it and find satisfaction in it.


User offline. Last seen 12 years 32 weeks ago.
Nich
Number 632
Conspirator for: 15 years 5 weeks
Posted on: October 23, 2009 - 11:22am #4

I was familar with that fact about We the Living;  there were a couple things I noticed that didn't seem to fall in line with what I read from Fountainhead and the Virtue of Selfishness, a couple traits in Kira that I couldn't figure out(such as the lack of a pride element).

I'll look back into what exactly I can do.  Thanks for the input


User offline. Last seen 14 years 17 weeks ago.
Number10980
Number 614
Conspirator for: 15 years 13 weeks
Posted on: October 28, 2009 - 3:48pm #5

I would like to see a libertarian youth organization that would be an alternative to the Boy/Girl Scouts, 4H and various other clubs. From my early teens through my twenties I was heavily involved with a 4H group and I've made many life long friends out of it but I look back and I wished that it didn't have so many statist and socialist leanings. I was all about the 4H pledge back when I was a good little citizen and when I look at it now I just shake my head.